Thu 2 Sep 2010
Jane Smiley’s writing for adults has been much admired, with a Pulitzer Prize and National Book Critics’ Circle Award for A Thousand Acres, but this is, as far as I know, her first foray into writing for younger readers. With recommendations on the cover from Meg Rosoff: “Passion for horses shines out of every page,” and Hilary McKay: “Wonderful storytelling,” it was almost guaranteed to be a great read, but as I’ve mentioned before, books can evoke very different responses in different readers. In this case I’m happy to concur with their enthusiasm. There are lots of books which feel as if they are almost exploiting the love of horses that exists in many a young reader, but this has a lot more to it. Abby has troubles at school, and her father, a horse-trading / farming born-again Christian who is very loving, but can be rather dogmatic, as her older brother has found. Danny now lives elsewhere. Abby loves the horse work on the farm, and is very good with horses, but there’s one gelding who won’t let her be friends and bucks her off as often as he can. Then Jem Jarrow turns up, a man who has a different way of looking at horses from Abby’s Dad, or her uncle, who makes things worse by attempting to dominate the horse. This book has the best horse scenes I’ve read since Silverhorse and its sequel, beautifully drawn characters and the “wonderful storytelling” Hilary McKay identified. Suitable for anyone who can read it, probably nine or ten up.








